Army found his body the following day, he was still clutching his rifle in one hand and holding his medical kit in the other. A lot of people are foggy enough about the battle of troys origins to confuse the story laid out in the iliad with history. The new, eightpart netflix historical drama series, troy. Nov 10, 2018 there is a bunch of truth to what happens, but its spun for story sake. Fall of a city is not associated with any historical records at all. The movie sidesteps the existence of the greek gods, turns its heroes into action movie cliches and demonstrates that were getting tired of computergenerated armies. In the story of the iliad, the trojan horse is the brilliant ploy that odysseus uses to sneak past the walls of troy and end the war. The film was adapted by homers great epic poem, the iliad. Produced by units in malta, mexico and britains shepperton studios, the film features an ensemble cast led by brad pitt, eric bana, and orlando bloom. The trojan war lasted for 10 years while in the movie it lasted in a few weeks. Troy, starring brad pitt, is a historical travesty film the guardian. To understand the battle of kadesh it is important to know how the egyptian army and their chariots operated. Apr 08, 2018 with the historical veracity of the trojan war itself remaining in doubt, the dramatic abduction of helen by paris obviously cannot be verified either. Some of the inaccuracies listed here test the movie by the content of the epics or the wider epic cycle, while others test it by what we know of the technology and culture of 12th century bc greece.
Historical accuracy of the movie troy 1493 words 6 pages the movie troy, from hollywood has been one of the greatest hollywood movie ever made, it was nominated for more than 10 awards and got into the best of warner bros 50 film collection. While investigating the movie s historical accuracy, we learned that when the u. Elena gottesman, rachel lee, and taylor wilson the trojan horse historical accuracy during the war, the greeks moved their ships and hid inside of a hollow wooden horse. Most of the characters in this movie never really existed although some are based on certain archetypes, and the major conflict that the movie portrayed is also entirely fictional. In the ancient greek world, there was always a lot of respect given to the king of the nation, whether he deserved it or not. Hitler rants in fury when he hears that no historical advisers will be used in his medieval film project. Historical accuracy of the movie troy the paper will be about the historical accuracy of the movie troy which tells the story of the trojan war.
From the costumes to the architecture of the city of troy this movie gets about as close as anyone could get to giving us an idea of what battles were like, or imagined to have been like, at the time when the iliad and the odyssey were reduced to writing. The most complete of these stories is the illiad which is attributed to a greek called homer. Fall of a city, coproduced with the bbc, is most obviously based on homers account of the trojan war in the iliad, but there are a number of other historical. Troy, based on the iliad, has proven to be a very loose adaptation of homers classic and one cannot help noticing the major differences between the. At best it is a mythic version of events that may or may not happened in real life. The 2004 troy movie is not historically accurate for the following reasons. How the movie troy doesnt even come close to historys history. Looking at its historical accuracy, we can find the good and bad representations as well as the truly ugly decisions that truly twist history. Shakespeares plays have been a source of entertainment. For more on the movie troy look for the commentary assessing the evidence for the trojan wars, on the archaeological institute of americas website by c. When examined meticulously, it is clearly evident however, that the film troy, is historically accurate as it is based on true facts from the ancient greek life. Nevertheless, as with most historical dramas, this movie was more about entertainment than historical narrative.
Instead, i viewed troy on bluray purely for its cinematic entertainment value as an evenings viewing of the popcorn variety of movie i was not disappointed, but boy do you need the whole evening free if you watch it in its entirety the standard uk disc contains only the directors cut as it runs in excess of a bumnumbing 3hrs. How the movie troy doesnt even come close to historys. It is loosely based on homers iliad in its narration of the entire story of the decadelong trojan warcondensed into little more than a. Mel gibson says apocalypto, his new movie set during the collapse of the maya empire, should not be seen as a historical document. Fall of a city, debuted this week on the streaming service, after running in the united kingdom on bbc one in february. And if you read the iliad subsequent to viewing troy, you will be further enlightened and find it even more accessible. At the start of the next shot, as the camera begins to pan down, on the far right, just beside a persons who is dressed in blue head is a metal bullhorn ie. Troy is a 2004 epic historical war drama film directed by wolfgang petersen and written by david benioff. The characters from the iliad were portrayed by many wellknown actors including, brad pitt, orlando bloom, and eric bana. The story comes from homers poem, but homer was writing some four centuries after the events shown in troy.
The movie troy, from hollywood has been one of the greatest hollywood movie ever made, it was nominated for more than 10 awards and got into the best of warner bros 50 film collection. There was a bullet hole in the forehead of the gas mask he was wearing. Detail from the procession of the trojan horse in troy by domenico. Hitler wants historical accuracy in movies youtube. Historical accuracy of the movie troy bestacademicexperts. The battle of megiddo was the first reliably recorded battle, and not long after the battle of kadesh would claim the title of the largest chariot battle ever, despite chariot warfare persisting for nearly 1,000 more years. However, there is an amount of historical accuracy in this sequence. Troy is just north of most major longdistance trade routes. Inaccuracies in the film troy would be inaccuracies from a mythical, not historical perspective. They match the costumes, props, set design, and more. Better a couple of hundred sweaty warriors than two masses of 50,000 men marching toward one another across a sea of. Brian rose, one of the directors of the current excavations at the site and a professor at the university of cincinnati, and see the troia projekt site. With the help of achilles, the greeks are able to fight the never before defeated trojans. The trojan war itself is, strictly speaking, not true history in the sense of the word.
Im sure youll hear more than one moviegoer comment on. They skip over the fundamental question whether we want to judge troy as an account of a historical war, or an adaptation of an ancient epic poem. Hes going to take the beach of troy with fifty men. Being a big girls blouse, the prince of troy is no match for the spartan king, who lumbers around whacking him with a sword for about 30 seconds until the. Troy, starring brad pitt, is a historical travesty film. A labor of love for director attenborough, the preamble wording above is perhaps in some way his excuse if the verisimilitude. Historical movie try their best to be as accurate as possible. While investigating the movies historical accuracy, we learned that when the u. The true story behind the netflix movie the king time. Troy the film troy was directed by wolfgang peterson and produced in 2004. Orlando bloom is an annoyingly spoiled paris and it is surprising that he is willing to play the role of someone this unlikable with such accuracy.
I changed no historical accuracy to very little if any historical accuracy, since although it hasnt been conclusivley proven it is likely that the iliad had its orgins in reality, but the degree that this is true is unknown hence the ambiguity in the edited statement. May 14, 2004 troy is based on the epic poem the iliad by homer, according to the credits. There is a bunch of truth to what happens, but its spun for story sake. At least with troy with brad pit was a movie that maximized my utility for entertainment as a young manteen. Better a couple of hundred sweaty warriors than two masses of 50,000 men marching toward one another across a sea.
In reality, an enormous wooden horse is an unlikely military. Hector is the prince of troy, who leads the trojan army in holding off the entire greek armada. Clearly, the historical accuracy of the film troy is yet again proved as it supports the facts from ancient greek religion. Troy viia can be highlighted by most of the population of. For example, the movie spans a matter of weeks when the real trojan war lasted a full decade. Egyptian warfare and the largest chariot battle in history. Smellin of troy what follows is a partial list of discrepancies between troy the bigbudget hollywood movie and troy the epic poem and archeological history. So to ask if any accountstorymovietv series concerning the trojan wa. In the audio commentary for apollo, lovell states that his problem with it is that the sequence did not actually happen. As achilles ship nears the trojan shores, agamemnon snidely asks, whats the fool doing. Film analysis troy 2004 historical accuracy of troy.
First off, the war supposedly lasted 10 years, not a few weeks as the movie showed. Troy is based on the epic poem the iliad by homer, according to the credits. D the trojan war was an epic siege carried out by the achaean greek kingdoms against the city of troy, around 1250 bc. James holoka, professor foreign languages and history at eastern michigan university, who notes that despite this list he did enjoy the movie. More than a century of archaeological and historical research in the eastern mediterranean basin appears to confirm that there was a war on troy when homer says there was. Troy, based on the iliad, has proven to be a very loose adaptation of homers classic and one cannot help noticing the major differences between the book and the. Oct 25, 2019 the true story behind the netflix movie the king. The trojans, thinking that the greeks had sailed away and left the horse as a. Also, i know that coins placed on the deceased were for crossing the river styx, but were they placed on the eyes, or under the tongue or either.
Historical accuracy of the movie troy pyramid essays. The trojan war was an epic siege carried out by the achaean greek kingdoms against the city of troy, around 1250 bc. Brad pitt is the perfect achilles and eric bana a suitably noble homer. Prior to the films release, and more so following, christian writers criticized the movies historical inaccuracies and its depiction of christians specifically. What are historical inaccuracies of the movie troy. In 2009, film director alejandro amenabar brought the story of hypatia of alexandria c. The whole movie shows their battle struggles and the foreshadowing of fate in this adaptation of homers classic the iliad.
Historical accuracy in the film agora ancient history. The story written is based on a series of tales which were designed to be told orally to a non literate audience. The accuracy is pretty off, theres more historical accuracy in xena warrior princess, then in this show. Another form of culture is the art through mainly architecture that is apparent in any nation that is on the rise to being one of the best. The paper will be about the historical accuracy of the movie troy which tells the story of the trojan war. There are many inaccuracies in the historical events depicted in troy, according to the historians. The far side of the worlds historical accuracy is a matter of some debate simply because of the nature of the films plot. So they set off with 1,000 ships holding 50,000 greeks to troy. Evidently, the film troy is historically accurate because it correctly portrays the respect given to women in the ancient greek class system. It may be unfair to classify troy vi as a trading center but we do know that troy vi was a prominent metropolis that did contribute to the trade of the region. Having said that, historical accuracy is endlessly fascinating, and this article points out some of the main areas where some of the biggest historical movies in recent decades have been faithful and where theyve differ from historical reality. A labor of love for director attenborough, the preamble wording above is perhaps in some way his excuse if. Historical inaccuracy a critical look into ron howards. There were many historical inaccuracies in the film and the historians who were hired to advise on the movie quit or refused to be given credits because of the many historical inaccuracies the final version had.
The 2004 epic film troy catches quite the break when it comes to historical films. The movie troy, from hollywood has been one of the greatest hollywood movie ever made, it was nominated for more than 10 awards and got into the best of. Despite the awesomeness that is the 300 film and the sequel the epic battles, the amazing directing, the incredible cinematography by zack snyder, and all the impressive special effects our mission in this site is very specific, and thus, this article. The battle of troy takes the jump from history books to film with little consideration, disregarding the storys historical accuracy and failing to entertain audiences with the kind of flashy. It is hectors brother, paris bloom, who steals the beautiful helen away from her husband, menelaus, the king of sparta, and prompts the war between greece and troy. Dec 08, 2006 mel gibson says apocalypto, his new movie set during the collapse of the maya empire, should not be seen as a historical document.